Some might say it’s typical of anglo media to run a story with the headline Ignore the alarmists, there is no language crisis in Quebec, economists say. Actually the piece is an interview with one economist, UdeM prof François Vaillancourt, who’s written a report with numbers showing, as the writer says, that Bill 101 has worked and French is now more dominant economically and numerically here than ever.
One, is there any sign of a language crisis? As I noted this weekend, the Fête nationale always brings a flurry of pieces about the perilous position of French, but it’s largely a gesture toward tradition.
And two, does an economist’s numbers really count against perceptions? It’s perceptions that get people out in the street, impel them to vote a certain way, change how they feel. As we’ve learned so far in this millennium, the successful politician needs to tinker with perceptions, not present cold hard facts.
And a minor three: if there’s one type of lede I despise, it’s an order to forget or ignore coming from a journalist or newspaper. Even when it’s something like “Forget foie gras, everyone’s eating poutine now!” I recoil. Tell your story, don’t order me around.
Reply