French: more updates
The PQ wants to get back to a number from 2011, it says, when 81% of us spoke French at home.
They want to do this by reducing immigration, being “more severe” with bilingual towns, and putting pressure on American video distribution services to have more French content.
But the thing here is that they want us speaking French at home. It is not enough that we speak French at work, in stores, in the street – we need to be French. And the only way to increase that number is to either import only native French speakers, or get French speakers to have more babies. Pushing women to have more babies is not a great look in our times – but you can hardly patrol which language people speak in their own homes. It’s a puzzle.
City hall opposition, seeing an opportunity to stir shit, has presented a petition signed by 18,000 people, to push the city to do more for French. This is, on the face of it, incredibly unwise: city hall, under all its changing administrations, has left language politics to the provincial government, and has concerned itself with running the city. It’s not elected to impose language laws nor should it, and if Denis Coderre succeeds in getting re-elected he may find himself in the inconvenient position of having to impose language laws on the kind of international big shots he most values.
Daniel 09:41 on 2021-05-17 Permalink
Every once in a while, some reasonable ideas emerge in all this. Pressure Netflix to have more French content? Sure. Why not. Offer more/better/cheaper French classes? Again, sure.
Reduce immigration? LOLZ. No. And the alarm bells ringing over the supposed decline of French at home? Eesh.
Some things seem like fine policy proposals. And then you have the parts that smack so clearly of the worst of identity politics.
steph 10:45 on 2021-05-17 Permalink
I’m just going to fill out the next census as monolingual french mother-tongue.
Kate 15:28 on 2021-05-17 Permalink
Daniel, I agree. Enrich the cultural scene here with more TV and video content in French, more live concerts and theatre when it becomes possible, support for more publishing in French – absolutely.
But it isn’t the city’s job to do this.
Ant6n 05:03 on 2021-05-18 Permalink
@Steph
That may also be shooting yourself in the foot. Once there very few anglos left on paper, they may decide minority protections aren’t necessary anymore. Basically there’s no winning.
Kevin 11:17 on 2021-05-18 Permalink
They already believe that minority protections aren’t necessary, because they don’t admit to any difference between an anglo born and raised in Quebec and an American.