The question of temporary foreign workers is percolating, with items about how businesses are suffering from losing workers.
But the phrasing here reveals a nastier side: CityNews ledes with a description of the federal limits to hiring low-wage temporary foreign workers. Nobody seems to inquire into the ethics of bringing people here, sometimes having them live in penury while doing our dirty work, sometimes allowing them to build a good life before telling them they can’t stay.
Quebec was complaining about too many foreign (and non‑francophone) workers, but Ottawa obliged them a little too enthusiastically. Now Quebec has flip‑flopped to complaining that Ottawa overdid things so that Quebec businesses are short of manpower – that cheap temporary disposable manpower everyone wants.




Uatu 21:29 on 2025-10-05 Permalink
Lot of out of province students could work some of these jobs… Oh wait…
Ian 22:43 on 2025-10-05 Permalink
It’s the conundrum of finally finding out that immigrants are not, in fact, ruining the economy…. but still having to figure out how to blame immigrants for ruining the economy. Why, it’s almost as if the ruling class is having us fight amongst ourselves …
roberto 07:36 on 2025-10-06 Permalink
Why play for values and consistency when you can just play low politics and throw mud.
azrhey 09:29 on 2025-10-06 Permalink
but but, if we bring in low wage temporary workers from the right corner of the world they will perform the right kind of public prayers! That should balance all the dangerous wrong kinds of public prayers, it’s a win win in my book!
( help yourself to a /sarc tag is you need one )
Joey 10:51 on 2025-10-06 Permalink
When the premier talks about trying to hold the together the two segments of the CAQ – those motivated by nationalism/identity and those motivated by economic issues (IOW xenophobia vs. greed) – I guess this is what he’s talking about. I don’t think we are prepared for the enthusiastic way in which capital is going to embrace AI robots.
Chris 11:07 on 2025-10-06 Permalink
There certainly has been a lot of flip flopping on the immigration issue.
You had leftists like Bernie Sanders arguing against mass immigration, as it can suppress wages for locals. Then you had other leftists convince many that making any argument against immigration makes you a total racist scumbag. And so, the population moved rightward on the issue, because why would you embrace those falsely accusing you of racism. And so, here we are. Sigh.
Ian 08:47 on 2025-10-07 Permalink
Bermio Sanders is American, their takes will always be a bit self-serving. Don’t fall fo the fallacy of appeal to authority, he has bad takes on lots of stuff. Even AOC, who is way more progressive than Sanders, has some weird takes.
That said, not all people against mass immigration are racists – but almost every racist is against mass immigration. That aside, realistically, Quebec is finding out waht a driver immigration is for our economy – even if they aren’t willing to acknowledge teh net social benefit of multiculturalism. Again, not all people against multiculturalism are racists, but …
Ian 08:48 on 2025-10-07 Permalink
Bermio was a heck of a typo, not some weird in-joke nickname 😉